Banana bread troubleshooting

Why Is My Banana Bread Gummy? Causes and Fixes

Banana bread is usually gummy because it is underbaked in the middle. Banana bread is a dense, wet batter, so the crust can look done long before the center is. An oven that runs cool, too much banana, and mixing the batter too much or too little are the other common causes. Where the gumminess is in the slice tells you which.

Find the Cause From the Slice

Cut a slice from the middle of the cooled loaf and find the row that matches.

Gummy banana bread patterns, causes, and the first fix
What you seeWhat it usually meansFirst move
A raw, gooey center, but the edges and crust look doneUnderbaked, often because the oven runs cooler than its dial or was not fully preheatedCheck the oven with an oven thermometer, preheat fully, and bake until the center reads 200 to 205掳F
A thin raw layer just under the top crustThe top is not getting enough heat in your ovenMove the rack up a notch, and tent the loaf with foil for the last third of the bake if the top browns too fast
A dense, gummy streak along the bottomThe batter was mixed too little or too much, or the baking soda is oldMix until the batter is smooth and even, for as long as the recipe says, but do not keep beating after that; test your leavener
Heavy, wet, and gummy all the way throughToo much banana for the amount of flourMeasure the mashed banana. King Arthur found extra banana made a heavier, almost gummy loaf that needed 5 to 10 more minutes
Rose, then sank in the middle with a gummy bandToo much leavening or overmixing made it rise more than it could holdMeasure baking soda and powder level, and stop mixing once the flour disappears
Gummy only when sliced warmThe crumb had not finished settingLet it cool completely in the pan and on a rack before slicing
Two banana bread slices on a cooling rack: the left slice has a dark crust and a wet, gummy streak through the middle, the right slice has an even, fully set crumb
Left: a gummy center under a dark crust, the outside finished before the middle. Right: baked through and set.Illustrative image generated for Elevation Baking.

How to Tell When Banana Bread Is Done

A toothpick is not a reliable test for banana bread, because bits of banana, chocolate chips, or nuts can fool it. King Arthur Baking recommends these checks instead:

  1. Use a thermometer. Push an instant-read thermometer down through the top center of the loaf and read it slowly as you pull it back out. The center should read 200 to 205掳F, and no part of the loaf should be under 200掳F. Gluten-free quick breads should reach 205 to 210掳F.
  2. Or use a paring knife, more than once. Push a thin knife into the center and look for wet batter. Repeat two or three times, because the first try often comes out clean even when the center is not.
  3. Know your oven. Many ovens run cooler than the dial or take far longer to preheat than the beep suggests. An oven thermometer on the center rack tells you the real temperature.

Already Cut Into a Gummy Loaf?

Once a loaf is sliced, putting it back in the oven does not help: the edges and crust dry out before the center cooks. Cut away the gummy part, or slice the loaf and cook the slices on a buttered griddle, like French toast.

Gummy Banana Bread at High Altitude

At altitude, King Arthur Baking suggests baking 15 to 25掳F hotter so the structure sets before the loaf over-rises. The hotter oven also browns the crust sooner, so the outside can look done before the center is. Colorado State University Extension says cake-like quick breads such as banana bread do best with its cake adjustments, which include using a little less leavening.

  • Reduce the leavening slightly so the loaf does not rise and then sink.
  • Use the thermometer check above rather than the recipe's time; altitude changes both.
  • If the top browns before the center is done, tent it loosely with foil for the last part of the bake.

For a recipe with the altitude changes already worked in, try the high-altitude banana bread recipe. To adjust your own, see how to adjust banana bread for altitude.

Gummy Banana Bread FAQ

How do I fix banana bread with a gooey center?

If you have already sliced it, putting it back in the oven will dry out the edges before the center cooks. Instead, cut away the gooey part, or slice the loaf and cook the slices on a griddle like French toast. Next time, bake until the center reads 200 to 205掳F.

What temperature should banana bread be inside when it is done?

Between 200 and 205掳F in the center, with no part of the loaf below 200掳F, according to King Arthur Baking. Gluten-free quick breads should reach 205 to 210掳F.

Why does my banana bread come out mushy or dense?

Too much banana, overmixing after the flour goes in, or old baking soda are the usual causes. Mix gently, measure the banana, and make sure your leavener is fresh.

Why is my banana bread gummy at the bottom?

A gummy bottom layer usually comes from mixing: too little leaves the batter without enough structure, and too much makes it rise and then sink. Old or too little leavener can cause it too.

Is a toothpick a good test for banana bread?

Not always. Pieces of banana, chocolate chips, or nuts can make a toothpick come out clean or dirty regardless. A thin paring knife, tested two or three times in the center, is better, and an instant-read thermometer is the most reliable.

Sources